South Africa's Special Investigating Unit (SIU) made 5 944 criminal referrals to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) between 2011 and August 2026. The NPA told Parliament that these referrals led to 570 registered police dockets, 91 court cases and 263 convictions.
The source says this does not mean thousands of referrals disappeared. Several referrals may have been combined into one docket, and not all contained enough evidence for prosecution. Parliament's concern was that the SIU, NPA and Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (Hawks) could not give a consistent, reconciled account of how individual referrals moved through the criminal justice system.
The SIU's investigation into the National Lotteries Commission shows the problem. The SIU made 19 criminal referrals to the NPA between 2022 and 2024. In May 2025, the SIU reported no recorded progress on 18 of them. By March 2026, the NPA had consolidated them into 16 matters, with two in court and 14 under investigation. The NPA cited the Hawks' difficulties appointing forensic accountants as a major cause of delay. The source says the Hawks later submitted dockets to prosecutors, and some were returned with requests for further investigation.
The source also describes delays in disciplinary referrals. The SIU's Tembisa Hospital investigation produced 116 disciplinary referrals concerning 13 officials. By September 2025, 108 had been delivered to the Gauteng Department of Health. As of October 2026, the SIU had not received feedback on the progress of its recommendations. The source states this does not establish that the department failed to act.
The author argues that existing rules show how institutions can be required to report on referrals. Under the Public Audit Act and Material Irregularity Regulations, public bodies must acknowledge Auditor-General referrals and report on progress. The Independent Police Investigative Directorate Act requires police commissioners to start disciplinary proceedings within 30 days of IPID recommendations. The source says similar reporting duties should be extended to other significant corruption referrals.
The SIU and NPA signed a memorandum of understanding in 2017, and the Hawks and police signed another in 2022. The source says the institutions still struggle to reconcile their figures. The Presidency, SIU and NPA, working with the State Information Technology Agency, developed a proof of concept for a Case Monitoring Mechanism to track SIU referrals to the NPA.