Hegseth remains under pressure after failed impeachment vote, analysts say

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth continues to face criticism over his leadership at the Pentagon, a week after an impeachment effort led by outgoing Republican Representative Thomas Massie failed. The House voted 211 to 204 on November 10 to block the measure. Eleven Democrats were absent.

Massie's eight articles of impeachment accused Hegseth of dismantling safeguards to protect civilian lives. They cited the bombing of an elementary school in Minab, Iran, which killed at least 120 children, according to the articles as reported.

Jasmine El-Gamal, a former Middle East adviser in the Pentagon, said the secretary of defense is "a powerful participant in shaping a war." She said targeting Hegseth alone would not be enough to secure accountability for decisions such as the US-Israel war on Iran. She said Hegseth works with the president and his advisers, and that calling him an "executor" or "sole architect" each misstates the picture.

Hala Rharrit, a former State Department official who resigned in protest of US involvement in Israel's war on Gaza, told Al Jazeera that Hegseth and other Pentagon officials likely drew up initial strike lists before advising Trump on final approval. She said Trump "would not get into the granularities of which targets to strike on day one."

Hegseth has rejected calls to resign. In a video posted two days after the midterm elections, he called his critics "deep-state radicals" and said the military should "stay the course" in the war against Iran.

Brian Finucane, a former State Department legal adviser, said Congress holds most war powers under the Constitution and could halt the fighting.