Five EU member states, Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Denmark and Greece, have announced plans to set up an offshore centre in Rwanda for people with no legal right to stay in Europe. The pilot is meant to test the bloc's newly agreed returns law, and officials hope to send 100 people from early next year. The governments say the scheme will curb illegal migration, dismantle smugglers' business models and relieve pressure on their populations. Those are aims that deserve scrutiny, not applause.
The central problem is the country chosen. The report notes that the United States State Department found in 2024 that Rwanda's security forces and civilian officials were able to commit human rights abuses with impunity, and critics also raise concerns about freedom of expression and forced labour. Sending people there, thousands of kilometres from the European Union, as French Green MEP Mélissa Camara put it, with no guarantees about their rights, is not a neutral logistical choice. It is a decision to place vulnerable people where their protection is weakest.
The governments argue the scheme is grounded in human rights law, and officials expect legal challenges. Alain Berset, secretary general of the Council of Europe, said it was not possible to be precise in advance about what return hubs would mean, and that any concrete case would have to be checked for compliance with the European convention on human rights. That is the right test. The EU should not launch a programme in the hope that courts will sort out its legality later, particularly when the people affected would be removed before they could easily contest anything.
Spanish prime minister Pedro Sánchez said there was no future or humanity in the plan, and rights organisations such as Picum warn it is bound to fail. Whatever the merits of that prediction, the political message is clear: Europe is trying to manage its migration anxieties by moving the problem out of sight. Describing these sites as 'welcome centres' does not change what they are. My view is that the five governments should halt the negotiations until independent human rights assessments are published and the Council of Europe's concerns are answered in full.