Pakistan's defence minister, Khwaja Asif, has said the country could have multiple new provinces as early as the New Year. He was careful to call this his own view and said he had no inside information. That candour is useful, because the proposal has so far produced more talk than text. Nearly four months after Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi first raised it publicly, no draft constitutional amendment, agreed number of provinces or timetable has been made public.

The case for smaller administrative units is not frivolous. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has spoken of 12 to 15 provinces, and Mustafa Kamal argues that powers and resources have been pulled into provincial capitals rather than reaching people. A population of about 250 million is hard to govern through four provinces, and the 2010 constitutional amendment meant to push powers down to districts and cities has not delivered. Those are serious problems, and they deserve a serious answer.

The problem is the route being discussed. Article 239 requires two-thirds majorities in both houses of parliament, and for a boundary change, two-thirds support in each affected provincial assembly, a threshold that would require 248 of 371 members in the Punjab Assembly and 112 of 168 in Sindh. Naqvi's suggestion that the public should decide, and Article 48(6)'s joint-sitting referendum, look like shortcuts. As constitutional lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii notes, a referendum asks a binary question and its result is not binding on those who ask it. Pakistan's three past referendums, held under military rulers, are a poor precedent for using the ballot to bypass the amendment process.

The timing argument makes this worse. Kamal himself tied the matter to the Senate elections due early next year and the June budget, saying whatever has to happen must happen before then. Reshaping the federation on a political calendar, with parties that have not formally discussed the matter in cabinet, invites the suspicion that the decision is being made elsewhere. Provinces created in haste will not solve governance problems that come from weak local institutions and unspent resources. The earlier Bahawalpur and South Punjab bill lapsed in 2013 precisely because the process ran out of time.

If new provinces are worth creating, the government should publish a draft amendment, name the proposed units and their financing, and let every provincial assembly debate it on the record. Taking the time to do that is not delay for its own sake. It is the only way the change can be durable and legitimate.