In Gidan Dare, near the BUA Cement plant in northwest Nigeria, residents describe wells that once reached water at three or four metres now requiring seventy metres or more. They describe mud houses cracking under heavy truck traffic and plant operations loud enough to disturb their sleep close to midnight. The International Finance Corporation says it confirmed "broad community support" for the expansion during an August 2022 site visit. Community leaders interviewed for the report do not recall being consulted before BUA expanded onto land their families had farmed for generations.

The climate side of the file is just as thin. Once its new lines are running, the plant will emit about 4.1 million tonnes of CO₂ a year, 2.9 million of them from the expansion. IFC approved $210 million for the project and classifies it as Category A, its highest environmental and social risk tier. Yet the file sets no reduction target and requires no independent verification of the emissions figures. Its main climate commitment is a promise that IFC's Climate Advisory arm "will support BUA integrate low-carbon solutions" in future. A promise of future advice is not a measurable commitment, and nobody outside the institution can check it.

The report also shows that IFC's published climate methodology allows a project to count as aligned with the Paris Agreement when a promise is present and verification is optional. For a high-risk cement expansion in one of the hardest industrial sectors to decarbonize, that is not a technicality. Cleaner cement is already financeable, as IFC's own calcined clay cement plant in Burkina Faso shows. Requiring an alternatives analysis before any cement investment would cost little compared with the harm borne by families who had no say in the decision.

IFC is currently revising its Sustainability Framework, with a first draft expected in the coming weeks. Executive Directors should use that revision to demand four things: a measured emissions baseline published before the board votes; independent verification of climate and community consultation claims before a project is labelled climate-aligned; an independent audit against a credible pathway such as the IEA Cement Roadmap as a condition of financing; and a completed analysis of lower-carbon alternatives before approval.

The people of Gidan Dare are not asking the board to take their word alone. They are asking for rules that make climate commitments binding and checkable. When accountability lapses, IFC does not absorb the cost; families living beside the plant do, and they have the least capacity to adapt. Climate finance should be able to prove what it promises.