A court in Mombasa has sentenced Paul Mackenzie to 200 years in prison, 100 years for murder by starvation and 100 years for direct homicide, for the deaths of 190 children and one adult. The sentence came two weeks after he was found guilty. Given what prosecutors described, with followers ordered to starve themselves and their children, victims beaten into compliance and some buried alive, a sentence of this length is a fitting judgment on the crimes.

Yet a verdict closes only one part of this disaster. The report notes that Mackenzie had been on the radar of authorities since 2017, when police searched his premises, and that his church was shut down in 2019 before he relocated to the Shakahola forest. Many questions remain about how a man under such scrutiny could keep followers isolated, children out of school and sick people away from hospitals for years. Those questions deserve public answers, not only a court record.

The scale of the failure is hard to overstate. More than 400 bodies have been recovered, only 26 could be identified, and investigations into more than 200 other deaths are continuing. Relatives first raised the alarm in March 2023, when a man told police his brother and wife had starved their children on Mackenzie's orders. Families should not have had to be the early warning system for a crisis of this size.

Kenya's government should now do three things. It should finish the investigations into the outstanding deaths and the 52 deaths in Kwa Binzaro that prosecutors have linked to Mackenzie while he was in detention. It should review how regulators and police handled earlier warnings. And it should tighten oversight of churches and religious organisations, a call the report says is already being made in a country where faith plays a prominent role in public life.

Oversight must protect religious freedom while preventing abuse. The aim is not to police belief but to ensure that no group can hide starving children behind a church name. Shakahola should be remembered as the moment Kenya chose to act on its warnings.